Locals Key West Pizza Eatery

Locals Key West Pizza Eatery

One of the places that locals know best is Joe's Counter Style Cafe, a cool pizza joint. Classically made in old style stone ovens. Nothing beats the cheaper eatery locations, so more cash goes to cocktails! Stop in for a delicious slice or two. Just down the street from the 801 Bourbon Bar (this place sticks out).
Alison R.

reader feedback

Eating like a local in Key West

Very good for sure, just the right temperature and plenty of cheese. Do not forget to add the little Peppers and ask for extra napkins. Finger licking food, it is so much quicker than ordering at a restaurant. We like to stay on the move. Way to go Joe!

Charlene A.

Key West Street-side Pizza

Yes the pizza is good here. I stop in and pick some up for our team from the Southernmost Bocce League. We have picnic tables with Beer and Pizza Monday to Thursday at the Bocce Park. My favorites are: Primo Vegetarian (Pesto sauce, fire roasted tomatoes, red Peppers, baby spinach, red onions, roasted garlic, formaggio, mozzarella), American Pizza (Wheat dough, organic tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, tomatoes, mushrooms, bell peppers, red onions), Hot Stuff (Beef, pepperoni, sausage, onions, jalapenos), Philly Steak (Grilled philly steak, mushrooms, ripe tomatoes, sweet onions, romano cheese, white pizza sauce), and the Four Cheese (Spicy tomato sauce with asiago, mozzarella, provolone and romano cheese). For sandwiches go to Goldman's Deli at 2796 North Roosevelt Blvd.

Lola L.

Joe's Cafe

724 Duval Street
Key West FL 33040

local map