Everything is Homemade

Everything is Homemade

Winner of the best cookies in Key West contest. No wonder the Mattheessen's locations are the most popular spots to stop and fulfill sweet taste sensations. Half pound cookies are wonderful to split with others. They even have one of their chefs perform live right there in the front of the store. Wow, does it smell so good inside.
Jodi H.

reader feedback

Best of the Island Sweet Shops

This is one of the best sweet treat cafes as you get to sample before you buy. You can get all sorts of homemade goodies, plus hamburgers and hotdogs done right.

Mattie M.

Super Yummy

The arrival of the bikini was popularized by the style icons that wore them and the food nibbled on. The real showstopper was the brown leather one-piece with tortoise shell accents. The earliest form of the female bathing suit was a bathing dress worn in the early 1800s. Go here for the preeminent of skinny snacks.

Joe G.

Homemade Everything

1110 White Street
Key West FL 33040
Related: best key west cookies

local map