Great homemade pizza is not difficult to find in the Florida Keys. Pile on the toppings, order it basic or as complex as you want to make it. They use the simple approach to the best taste, skipping the prepackaged ingredients. Pizza is more time-consuming to make with fresh veggies and scratch ingredients.
My favorite is the hawaiian pizza that is loaded up with cuban smoked ham, mozzarella cheese, bacon bits, pineapple, green Peppers, and extra sauce. The hot stuff beef is the one a fishing captain would buy with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and jalapenos mixed up on top. The shop is really cute and a lot of fun to eat inside. We tend to do pizza to go and eat back at the hotel or on the dock, but the atmosphere inside is so nice I like it.
Onions are super for pizza. I will bring three yellow onions, if you want more just let me know. I have just now put the onions in the car so I do not forget! The plan is to go early for Picking up the Live Bait in Islamorada and then go fishing with the pizza to eat. It seems to me we picked the all good Boater Hotel close to all.