One of the restaurants in the Holiday Isle Entertainment Area has a make your own burger menu. I love being able to pick out all the different types of veggies, cheese types, and sauces. Keeping things family friendly and interesting is the Shula Burger. The burgers are great to-go, pick some up and there is a waterfront picnic park just about a long field goal away.
Question: Can you get alcohol at the Shula Burger in Islamorada? Answer: Yes you can get all sorts of beer and wine. There are a bunch of other Tiki bars and restaurants within a mile. Alcohol is a heavily used commodity of pirate island life!