The best Italian on the Island

The best Italian on the Island

Our vacation stay in the Florida Keys was for two-weeks, which gave us plenty of time to try a whole new series of restaurants. On this trip La Trattoria was the shining star, with spaghetti pasta and fettuccine alfredo dishes that pleased everyone in our group. I would try dining here and Nine One Five Bistro, Old Town Mexican Cafe, and Mrs Macs Kitchen for some yummy treats that are a bit different that the traditional grilled shrimp.
Mollie W.

reader feedback

We love the Variety of Florida Keys Restaurants

Using the cooker, I made spaghetti and handrolled meatballs tonight, just like the way they make them here at the Restaurant. I loved it so much, I got inspired. What a treat.

Ignacio H.

The best Key West Italian Restaurant

Their menu is huge and loaded with all sorts of great Italian recipes. I just love Italian, especially after all the walking around the city. My favorite dish is the Italian Sausage Pasta with rigatoni pasta, roasted Peppers & spicy marinara sauce.

Alton M.

Hot Supreme Pizza the Italian Way

Try the recipes and menu at Vito's, very good and the pricing is a lot better. My favorites include the Portabella Mushroom Sub, which has the portabella mushroom prepared and served on a ciabatta roll with mixed field greens, roasted red Peppers, onions and fresh mozzarella. You will like the Supreme Pizza or pick out your top ingredients. I like to put pepperoni, sausage, black olives, bacon, mushrooms, green bell peppers, red peppers and loads of onions on top.

Samual L.

Here you can get Spaghetti and Meatballs

I was so impressed with the flavors blended into the Spaghetti & Meatballs. The restaurant uses large meatballs in the recipe on spaghetti pasta and it goes so nice with toasted bread. Another good menu pick is the Chicken Bruchetta.

Kenya O.

La Trattoria

524 Duval Street
Key West FL 33040

local map